Mean Squared Displacement: Difference between revisions

From bradwiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:


Finding the MSD ([http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mean_squared_displacement not a trivial task]) of the simulation was done using a Matlab toolbox (see video below). The target extrasynaptic MSD was '''0.1 <sup>µm&sup2;</sup>&frasl;<sub>s</sub>''' (from Choquet {{Fig|[[File:ChoquetDiffusionRate1.png]]}}). Scaling the model to real-world values based on the target MSD was a 2-step process. First, the randomly generated step-size was scaled to produce an MSD of '''0.1 <sup>units&sup2;</sup>&frasl;<sub>step</sub>''' using the Matlab Brownian motion toolbox. Second, the dimensions of the model were scaled to make '''0.1 <sup>units&sup2;</sup>&frasl;<sub>step</sub>''' &asymp; '''0.1 <sup>µm&sup2;</sup>&frasl;<sub>s</sub>'''. It was found that an XY random step-size of µ{{=}}0.5 (&sigma;{{=}}.2) units produced an MSE &asymp; '''0.1 <sup>units&sup2;</sup>&frasl;<sub>step</sub>'''. Then, the arbitrary 0.5 units were given meaning (converted to 0.5 µm) by scaling the model according to real-world values (see below) by making 1 unit {{=}} 1 µm; as a convention, a ''subunit'' will be 1/10th of a unit, thus 1 subunit {{=}} 0.1 µm). The PSD areas were set to 3-subunits (.3 µm) square, 20 subunits (2 µm) apart, within a rectangular field 20 subunits (2 µm) wide and 60 subunits (6 µm) long. Given these scaled dimensions where 10 subunits &asymp; 1 µm, a particle with an XY step-size of 0.5 units moving in a straight line, could theoretically go from PSD1 to PSD2 in 4 steps (obviously given the simulated particles are moving with Brownian motion, this lower-bound would be extremely rare).  
Finding the MSD of the simulation is ([http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mean_squared_displacement a trivial task]) using a Matlab toolbox (see video below). The target extrasynaptic MSD was '''0.1 <sup>µm&sup2;</sup>&frasl;<sub>s</sub>''' (from Choquet {{Fig|[[File:ChoquetDiffusionRate1.png]]}}). Scaling the model PSD size and distance between synapses to real-world values based on the target MSD is not a trivial task, and may actually be related only indirectly. Just because a particle moves quickly, does not mean it moves from A to B quickly - it depends on how much stuff there is to collide with. Linear estimates have shown that glycine receptor movements along dendrites at a speed of 1–2 µm/min (.016-.008 µm/s).
 
 
First, the randomly generated step-size was scaled to produce an MSD of '''0.1 <sup>units&sup2;</sup>&frasl;<sub>step</sub>''' using the Matlab Brownian motion toolbox. Second, the dimensions of the model need to be scaled. It was found that an XY random step-size of µ{{=}}0.4 (&sigma;{{=}}.2) units produced an MSE &asymp; '''0.1 <sup>units&sup2;</sup>&frasl;<sub>step</sub>'''. Next, the arbitrary 0.5 units need to be given meaning...
 
 
 




[[File:ScaleModel.png]]
[[File:ScaleModel.png]]


here are two good resources explaining MSD:
*[http://mathworld.wolfram.com/RandomWalk2-Dimensional.html wolfram alpha]
*[http://www.compsoc.man.ac.uk/~lucky/Democritus/Theory/msd.html Democritus]


{{ExpandBox|VIDEO|
{{ExpandBox|VIDEO|
Line 25: Line 35:
*given an MSD of {{Button|0.52 ±0.2 units&thinsp;&sup2;/s}} at the current parameters: 1 step {{=}} 1 unit (at µ{{=}}1,&sigma;{{=}}.2), the model will need to be scaled such that particles move at an extrasynaptic rate of 0.1 µm&thinsp;&sup2;/s.
*given an MSD of {{Button|0.52 ±0.2 units&thinsp;&sup2;/s}} at the current parameters: 1 step {{=}} 1 unit (at µ{{=}}1,&sigma;{{=}}.2), the model will need to be scaled such that particles move at an extrasynaptic rate of 0.1 µm&thinsp;&sup2;/s.
*spines are on average 1 to 10 µm apart, if the model is comparing two spines 1 µm apart, they should be separated by 5 units of model space. This is because the current particle diffusion rate of the model is .5 µm&thinsp;&sup2;/s and the empirical MSD is .1 µm&thinsp;&sup2;/s
*spines are on average 1 to 10 µm apart, if the model is comparing two spines 1 µm apart, they should be separated by 5 units of model space. This is because the current particle diffusion rate of the model is .5 µm&thinsp;&sup2;/s and the empirical MSD is .1 µm&thinsp;&sup2;/s
----
to make '''0.1 <sup>units&sup2;</sup>&frasl;<sub>step</sub>''' &asymp; '''0.1 <sup>µm&sup2;</sup>&frasl;<sub>s</sub>'''. It was found that an XY random step-size of µ{{=}}0.4 (&sigma;{{=}}.2) units produced an MSE &asymp; '''0.1 <sup>units&sup2;</sup>&frasl;<sub>step</sub>'''. Then, the arbitrary 0.5 units were given meaning (converted to 0.5 µm) by scaling the model according to real-world values (see below) by making 1 unit {{=}} 1 µm; as a convention, a ''subunit'' will be 1/10th of a unit, thus 1 subunit {{=}} 0.1 µm). The PSD areas were set to 3-subunits (.3 µm) square, 20 subunits (2 µm) apart, within a rectangular field 20 subunits (2 µm) wide and 60 subunits (6 µm) long. Given these scaled dimensions where 10 subunits &asymp; 1 µm, a particle with an XY step-size of 0.5 units moving in a straight line, could theoretically go from PSD1 to PSD2 in 4 steps (obviously given the simulated particles are moving with Brownian motion, this lower-bound would be extremely rare).


}}<!-- END BOX -->
}}<!-- END BOX -->

Revision as of 02:03, 5 August 2013

Finding the MSD of the simulation is (a trivial task) using a Matlab toolbox (see video below). The target extrasynaptic MSD was 0.1 µm²s (from Choquet FIG: {{#info: {{{2}}} CLICK AWAY FROM IMAGE TO CLOSE }}). Scaling the model PSD size and distance between synapses to real-world values based on the target MSD is not a trivial task, and may actually be related only indirectly. Just because a particle moves quickly, does not mean it moves from A to B quickly - it depends on how much stuff there is to collide with. Linear estimates have shown that glycine receptor movements along dendrites at a speed of 1–2 µm/min (.016-.008 µm/s).


First, the randomly generated step-size was scaled to produce an MSD of 0.1 units²step using the Matlab Brownian motion toolbox. Second, the dimensions of the model need to be scaled. It was found that an XY random step-size of µ=0.4 (σ=.2) units produced an MSE ≈ 0.1 units²step. Next, the arbitrary 0.5 units need to be given meaning...




here are two good resources explaining MSD:

VIDEO


{{{2}}}


MEAN SQUARED DISPLACEMENT



Brownian Motion Mean Squared Displacement
  • The goal of this calculation is to relate the simulated particle diffusion to real world values, namely velocity.
  • Particle velocity will be a function of MSD x units ²⁄s which scales on space (units) and time (s) parameters.
  • Space and time in the model are defined arbitrarily as Step_Size and Step where each Step a particle moves a distance randomly chosen from a normal distribution (µ=1,σ=.2)
  • a step size of 1 unit/step will produce a brownian motion MSD of ~0.52 ±0.2 units ²/s
  • empirical observations show that reasonable values for MSD are:
    • PSD 0.01 µm ²/s
    • synaptic 0.05 µm ²/s
    • extrasynaptic 0.1 µm ²/s
  • given an MSD of 0.52 ±0.2 units ²/s at the current parameters: 1 step = 1 unit (at µ=1,σ=.2), the model will need to be scaled such that particles move at an extrasynaptic rate of 0.1 µm ²/s.
  • spines are on average 1 to 10 µm apart, if the model is comparing two spines 1 µm apart, they should be separated by 5 units of model space. This is because the current particle diffusion rate of the model is .5 µm ²/s and the empirical MSD is .1 µm ²/s



to make 0.1 units²step0.1 µm²s. It was found that an XY random step-size of µ=0.4 (σ=.2) units produced an MSE ≈ 0.1 units²step. Then, the arbitrary 0.5 units were given meaning (converted to 0.5 µm) by scaling the model according to real-world values (see below) by making 1 unit = 1 µm; as a convention, a subunit will be 1/10th of a unit, thus 1 subunit = 0.1 µm). The PSD areas were set to 3-subunits (.3 µm) square, 20 subunits (2 µm) apart, within a rectangular field 20 subunits (2 µm) wide and 60 subunits (6 µm) long. Given these scaled dimensions where 10 subunits ≈ 1 µm, a particle with an XY step-size of 0.5 units moving in a straight line, could theoretically go from PSD1 to PSD2 in 4 steps (obviously given the simulated particles are moving with Brownian motion, this lower-bound would be extremely rare).


Michalet • 2010 • Phys Rev E Stat Nonlin Soft Matter Phys - PDF

Expand to view experiment summary



We examine the capability of mean square displacement analysis to extract reliable values of the diffusion coefficient D of single particle undergoing Brownian motion in an isotropic medium in the presence of localization uncertainty. The theoretical results, supported by simulations, show that a simple unweighted least square fit of the MSD curve can provide the best estimate of D provided an optimal number of MSD points is used for the fit. We discuss the practical implications of these results for data analysis in single-particle tracking experiments.